⚠️ Safety Verdict: Probably Safe (Use Caution)
E954 (Saccharin) is approved and considered safe by modern science. The 1970s cancer scare was debunked – rat bladder tumours don't occur in humans. However, some studies suggest links to gut bacteria disruption and glucose intolerance. Use in moderation.
💡 The Cancer Scare That Changed Everything
In the 1970s, studies showed saccharin caused bladder cancer in male rats, leading to health warnings and near-ban in the US.
What we now know:
- Rat bladder tumours occurred due to a mechanism specific to male rats (calcium phosphate crystals)
- Humans don't have this mechanism
- 30+ years of human studies found no cancer link
- In 2000, saccharin was removed from US carcinogen list
Verdict: The cancer scare was a false alarm.
What is E954 (Saccharin)?
E954 is saccharin, the world's oldest artificial sweetener (discovered accidentally in 1879).
Forms:
- Saccharin (pure form – rarely used, bitter)
- Sodium saccharin (most common)
- Calcium saccharin
Sweetness:
- 300-400 times sweeter than sugar
- Metallic/bitter aftertaste at high concentrations
- Often blended with other sweeteners to mask aftertaste
Why it's used:
- Zero calories
- Cheap – far less expensive than newer sweeteners
- Heat stable – survives baking and cooking
- Doesn't raise blood sugar
Where is Saccharin Found?
Diet Drinks & Foods:
- Diet soft drinks (especially older formulations)
- Low-calorie squash and cordials
- Sugar-free chewing gum
- Diabetic foods
Table-top Sweeteners:
- Sweet'N Low (pink packets – mainly saccharin)
- Hermesetas (contains saccharin)
- Generic saccharin tablets
Other Foods:
- Low-calorie jams and preserves
- Sugar-free desserts
- Some baked goods
- Pickles (as preservative enhancer)
Non-Food Uses:
- Toothpaste
- Mouthwash
- Chewable vitamins
- Medicines (to mask bitter taste)
Is Saccharin Safe? Modern Science Verdict
✅ Cancer Risk: Debunked
After 30+ years of research:
- NTP (US): Removed saccharin from carcinogen list in 2000
- IARC (WHO): Downgraded from "possibly carcinogenic" to not classifiable
- Large human studies: No link to bladder cancer, even at high doses
Why rats got cancer but humans don't: Male rats produce proteins and minerals that form crystals in the bladder with saccharin, causing irritation and tumours. Humans don't produce these proteins.
⚠️ Modern Concerns (Gut Health & Metabolism)
Newer research suggests potential issues unrelated to cancer:
1. Gut Bacteria Disruption
- Studies show saccharin alters gut microbiome composition
- May reduce beneficial bacteria
- Could affect overall gut health
2. Glucose Intolerance
- Some studies found saccharin worsened glucose tolerance in mice and humans
- Mechanism: gut bacteria changes affect metabolism
- Ironic – marketed for diabetics but may harm blood sugar control
3. Weight Gain Paradox
- Despite zero calories, some studies link artificial sweeteners to weight gain
- Possible reasons: increased cravings, altered gut hormones, metabolic confusion
Side Effects (Some People):
- Allergic reactions (rare) – hives, itching
- Headaches in sensitive individuals
- Digestive upset
Regulatory Status
UK/EU: Approved with ADI of 5mg per kg body weight
US: FDA approved – removed from carcinogen list in 2000
Canada: Approved since 2014 (was banned 1977-2014 due to rat studies)
Saccharin vs Other Sweeteners
| Sweetener |
Pros |
Cons |
| Saccharin (E954) |
Very cheap, heat stable, no cancer risk |
Bitter aftertaste, gut bacteria concerns |
| Aspartame (E951) |
No aftertaste, widely studied |
Not heat stable, PKU warning |
| Sucralose (E955) |
Heat stable, no aftertaste |
Expensive, possible gut concerns |
| Stevia (E960) |
Natural origin |
Licorice aftertaste, expensive |
Who Should Avoid Saccharin?
❌ Must Avoid:
- People with saccharin allergy (rare)
- Those with sulfonamide allergy (cross-reactivity possible)
⚠️ Consider Limiting:
- People with diabetes – paradoxically may worsen glucose control
- Those with gut health issues (IBS, dysbiosis)
- Pregnant women – limited safety data, use moderation
- Anyone trying to lose weight – artificial sweeteners may not help
The Bottom Line
- ✅ Cancer scare debunked – rat studies don't apply to humans
- ✅ Approved worldwide – considered safe by regulators
- ⚠️ Gut bacteria concerns – alters microbiome composition
- ⚠️ May worsen glucose tolerance – ironic for diabetic product
- ⚠️ Weight loss not guaranteed – may increase cravings
- ⚠️ Bitter aftertaste – often blended with other sweeteners
- ✅ Very cheap and heat stable – practical for manufacturers
Our recommendation: Saccharin is probably safe in moderation, but newer research on gut health and metabolism raises questions. If using artificial sweeteners, consider rotating different types rather than relying on one. Better yet, gradually reduce sweetness preference by cutting back on all sweeteners (artificial and natural).
🔍 Track E954 with NutraSafe
Scan barcodes to identify saccharin and all artificial sweeteners in your food.
Try NutraSafe Now
Last updated: February 2026