Switching From MyFitnessPal? Here’s Why

What MyFitnessPal Does Well

Let us be fair. MyFitnessPal deserves credit for several things it genuinely does better than most competitors:

• Massive food database — Over 14 million foods logged by users and verified entries. If a food exists, MFP probably has it somewhere.
• Social features — Friends, community forums, and shared meal plans create accountability that many people find motivating.
• Third-party integrations — Connects with Garmin, Fitbit, Apple Watch, and dozens of other fitness platforms.
• Established brand trust — It has been around since 2005. People know it, and their GPs and personal trainers recommend it.
• Exercise logging — Comprehensive exercise database with calorie burn estimates and activity tracking.

If calorie counting and macros are your only concern, and you do not mind a US-centric experience, MyFitnessPal still works. There is no need to switch for the sake of switching.

Where MyFitnessPal Falls Short for UK Users

The problems with MFP are not about what it does — they are about what it does not do, and how its US focus affects accuracy for British users.

The database is US-centric

MyFitnessPal was built in the United States, and it shows. When you search for a UK product, you often get American versions first. Portion sizes default to cups and ounces rather than grams. Nutritional values may not match what is printed on UK packaging because the US and UK use different labelling standards — the UK follows EU-derived regulations with per-100g values, while the US uses “per serving” with different reference amounts.

This means a UK user logging a Tesco sandwich or a Greggs sausage roll may be working with inaccurate data without realising it.

No additive or E-number information

MyFitnessPal tells you about calories, protein, carbs, and fat. It does not tell you anything about the additives in your food — no E-number identification, no safety information, no flagging of controversial ingredients. For the growing number of UK consumers interested in what is in their food beyond macros, this is a significant gap.

No reaction or symptom tracking

If you suspect certain foods are causing bloating, headaches, skin flare-ups, or digestive issues, MFP offers no way to log symptoms alongside meals. You would need a separate app for that — and then you lose the ability to correlate food and symptoms automatically.

Paywall creep

Features that were once free in MyFitnessPal have progressively moved behind the Premium paywall. Scanning barcodes, viewing macronutrient breakdowns, and accessing certain food insights now require a subscription. The free tier has become increasingly limited, which frustrates long-term users who remember when these features were included at no cost.

No AI nutrition coaching

MyFitnessPal provides data, but it does not interpret it for you in a personalised way. There is no AI coach analysing your weekly patterns, identifying nutritional gaps, or suggesting practical improvements based on your actual eating habits.

Side-by-Side Comparison

Here is an honest look at how the two apps compare across features that matter most to UK users:

What NutraSafe Adds That MFP Cannot

The features that set NutraSafe apart are not minor additions — they represent a fundamentally different approach to food tracking. Rather than just counting calories, NutraSafe helps you understand the full picture of how food affects you.

UK food database built for British shoppers

NutraSafe’s database is built around UK supermarket products, with nutritional data that matches what you see on British packaging. Portion sizes are in grams and millilitres by default, and UK-specific products from Tesco, Sainsbury’s, Aldi, Lidl, and other major retailers are properly represented. No more scrolling past American entries to find your actual product.

Additive scanner with E-number database

Scan any barcode and NutraSafe will identify every additive in the product, explain what each one does, and provide current safety information based on EFSA and FSA assessments. This is particularly valuable for parents checking children’s snacks, or anyone trying to reduce their intake of certain additives.

Food reaction and symptom tracking

Log how you feel after meals — energy levels, digestive comfort, skin reactions, headaches, mood — and NutraSafe helps you spot patterns over time. This is something the NHS recommends for identifying food intolerances, and NutraSafe makes it practical without needing a paper diary or separate app.

AI nutrition coach

NutraSafe’s AI coach analyses your food diary weekly, identifies nutritional gaps and patterns, and provides personalised suggestions. It is not generic advice — it is based on what you have actually been eating, tailored to your goals and preferences.

Cleaner, calmer interface

MyFitnessPal’s interface has become cluttered over the years with ads, upsells, and feature bloat. NutraSafe takes a more intentional design approach — clean, uncluttered, and focused on the information you actually need without visual noise.

Who Should Switch to NutraSafe

Switching apps is a decision worth thinking about carefully. Here is who will benefit most from making the move:

• UK users frustrated with US food data — If you are constantly correcting portion sizes or searching for British products that are not in the MFP database, NutraSafe will save you time and improve accuracy.
• People interested in food additives — If you care about what is in your food beyond just macros — E-numbers, ultra-processed markers, ingredient quality — MFP simply does not offer this.
• Anyone tracking food reactions — If you suspect food intolerances or want to understand how diet affects how you feel, NutraSafe’s integrated symptom tracking is genuinely useful.
• Parents checking children’s food — Scanning school snacks and lunchbox items for the Southampton Six and other additives of concern is straightforward with NutraSafe.
• People who want AI-powered insights — If you want your food diary to actually tell you something useful each week, rather than just storing data, the AI coach fills that gap.

Who Should Stay With MyFitnessPal

NutraSafe is not for everyone, and we would rather you make the right choice than switch for the wrong reasons:

• Social accountability seekers — If the community, friends list, and forum discussions are what keep you motivated, MFP’s social features are stronger.
• Gym-focused macro trackers — If your primary goal is hitting precise protein/carb/fat targets for bodybuilding or athletic performance, and you need extensive exercise integration, MFP’s ecosystem is more mature.
• Users heavily invested in third-party integrations — If your Garmin, Fitbit, or Peloton data flowing into MFP is essential to your routine, switching may disrupt that workflow.
• People tracking primarily non-UK foods — If you frequently eat international foods and rely on MFP’s enormous global database, NutraSafe’s more focused UK database may not cover everything you need.

Making the Switch: What to Expect

If you decide to try NutraSafe, here is what the transition looks like in practice:

• Download and set up takes 2 minutes — Create an account, set your goals, and you are ready to start logging.
• Start logging fresh — Rather than importing old data, begin with a clean slate. This ensures all your entries use accurate UK nutritional data from the start.
• Try both apps side by side for a week — There is no need to go cold turkey. Use both for a week and see which one feels more useful for your specific needs.
• Explore the extras — Spend time with the additive scanner and reaction tracking features. These are the areas where the difference is most noticeable.
• Give the AI coach a full week — The weekly assessment needs at least 5-7 days of food diary data to provide meaningful, personalised insights.

Frequently Asked Questions

Related Resources

Explore more comparisons and guides for UK food tracking: