It raises uric acid, which matters for gout
Disodium guanylate is a purine. The body breaks it down into uric acid. In people who already make too much uric acid or clear it poorly, extra purines can raise blood uric acid and set off or worsen gout attacks. What comes from additives adds to the purines in red meat, offal and some fish.
In a large study of men, those who ate the most meat and seafood, the main sources of purines, had more gout.
2004ObservationalChoi HK et al., New England Journal of Medicine
UK gout guidance advises people with gout to cut down on purine-rich foods.
2017Clinical guidanceBritish Society for Rheumatology guidelines on gout
The MSG reaction question
E627 is nearly always used with MSG, and some people blame headaches or flushing on foods containing the pair. Blinded trials have not shown that MSG at meal-sized amounts causes these effects reliably, and they did not test guanylate on its own. On a real label the two nearly always come together.
Blinded trials of MSG at amounts like those in a meal found no consistent reactions in people who said they were sensitive to it. The effect of added guanylate was not tested separately.
2000Randomised trial in peopleGeha RS et al., Journal of Nutrition
The only verdict is from 1990, and the review is still open
E627 is allowed because of a 1990 review by the EU's Scientific Committee on Food, which set no numerical daily limit for the ribonucleotides (E626 to E635) as a group. European reviewers are looking at the group again, and have said they are missing data on how most of these additives are made and what impurities they carry.
The current approval of E626 to E635 rests on a 1990 opinion of the Scientific Committee on Food, which set a group daily limit of not specified.
2024Regulator reviewEFSA, re-evaluations of food additives: ongoing and upcoming calls for data
Reviewers said there is no information on manufacturing, impurities and solubility for most of the ribonucleotides, and that they would draft their opinion with these data gaps.
2024Regulator reviewEFSA, re-evaluations of food additives: ongoing and upcoming calls for data
It may come from fish, and the label will not say
Disodium guanylate can be made from dried fish, from yeast or by fermentation. So it may not be vegan, and it could in principle carry traces of fish protein, depending on how well it is purified. Makers do not usually say which source they used.
Disodium guanylate is made from dried fish or from yeast. How much fish protein remains depends on the purification, and the source is not consistently shown on labels.
Regulator reviewFood and Agriculture Organization / WHO Joint Expert Committee on Food Additives (JECFA) monograph on guanylic acid