It raises uric acid, which matters for people with gout
Inosinate is a purine, and the body turns purines from food into uric acid, which the kidneys clear. In people with gout, high uric acid or poor kidney function, extra purines can push uric acid high enough to form crystals in the joints, setting off painful flare-ups. Most of the evidence is about high-purine foods such as offal and sardines, not additive amounts, and the dose from an additive is small. The concern is real but depends on how much is eaten.
In people with gout, eating a lot of purines over two days was linked to a much higher risk of another gout attack, whether the purines came from animal or plant foods.
2012ObservationalZhang Y et al., Annals of the Rheumatic Diseases
The ribonucleotides, E631 included, are purines, which the body breaks down into uric acid.
1990Regulator reviewEU Scientific Committee on Food, opinion on ribonucleotides
It may come from animals, and the label will not say
Disodium inosinate can be made from pig meat or fish, or by bacterial fermentation. Sources disagree on which is more common: the Vegetarian Society says animal sources are more widespread, while the Vegetarian Resource Group found the three leading makers all use fermentation. UK labelling rules do not require the source to be stated, so E631 on its own does not tell you.
Disodium inosinate may be made from meat (pork) or fish, or by bacterial fermentation. The method is not shown on food labels.
Regulator guidanceUK Food Standards Agency, approved additives technical guidance
The only verdict is from 1990, and the review is still open
E631 is allowed because of a 1990 review by the EU's Scientific Committee on Food, which set no numerical daily limit for the ribonucleotides (E626 to E635) as a group. European reviewers are looking at the group again. They have said they are missing data on how most of these additives are made and what impurities they carry, and they are going ahead with the review despite those gaps.
The current approval of E626 to E635 rests on a 1990 opinion of the Scientific Committee on Food, which set a group daily limit of not specified.
2024Regulator reviewEFSA, re-evaluations of food additives: ongoing and upcoming calls for data
Reviewers said there is no information on manufacturing, impurities and solubility for most of the ribonucleotides, and that they would draft their opinion with these data gaps.
2024Regulator reviewEFSA, re-evaluations of food additives: ongoing and upcoming calls for data