Animal toxicology: kidney and bladder findings at high doses
A 90-day rat study found kidney changes and urinary bladder hyperplasia at very high doses (roughly 5,900 mg per kg of body weight per day). Long-term rat studies also showed kidney mineral deposits (pelvic nephrocalcinosis) at elevated exposures. EFSA concluded these specific kidney effects were not relevant to humans because rats are unusually sensitive to this type of injury, and typical food exposure is far below the doses tested. However, these were the effects that set the toxicological upper limit for the assessment.
A 90-day rat study established a no-observed-adverse-effect level of 5,900 mg/kg body weight per day, based on urinary bladder hyperplasia and kidney changes.
2017AnimalEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources (ANS), re-evaluation of modified starches including E 1451
Long-term rat studies showed pelvic nephrocalcinosis (kidney mineral deposits) at high intake levels; the Panel considered this effect specific to the rat model and not predictive of human risk.
2017AnimalEFSA Journal, re-evaluation of modified starches (E 1404, E 1410-E 1452)
Genotoxicity assessed by modelling only, not direct testing
EFSA did not require direct genotoxicity tests for E1451, instead using computer-based structural analysis (in silico) of its chemical subunits. The Panel concluded there was no reason to suspect genotoxic potential. No in vitro or in vivo genotoxicity studies specific to E1451 were conducted or required. This approach is standard for modified starches but means direct test data do not exist for this specific form.
EFSA applied in silico analysis and concluded modified starches, including E1451, do not raise concern for genotoxicity, without requiring dedicated in vitro or in vivo tests.
2017LabEFSA Journal, re-evaluation of modified starches (E 1451 and related)
Data gap: how the body handles E1451 is not fully characterised
EFSA noted that absorption, distribution, metabolism and excretion (ADME) data were absent specifically for E1451 and one other modified starch (E1452). The Panel bridged this gap by reading across from better-studied related starches in the same group, concluding the overall database was sufficient for adults. The Panel did not close the gap with new data, and it remains a documented limitation in the formal assessment.
The EFSA Panel noted the absence of ADME data for E1451 (and E1452) specifically, and applied a read-across approach from structurally similar modified starches to compensate.
2017Regulatory reviewEFSA Panel on Food Additives and Nutrient Sources (ANS), re-evaluation of modified starches including E 1451
Infant use: EFSA recommended further data generation
E1451 is authorised at up to 50,000 mg/kg in a narrow category of dietary foods for babies and young children for special medical purposes. During the 2017 re-evaluation, EFSA recommended that additional safety data be generated for this use specifically, citing the vulnerability of infants and the relatively high permitted maximum level in this category. This recommendation to generate further data is a formal concern on record, distinct from the position for adults.
EFSA recommended data generation to address safety for infants, noting the maximum permitted level of 50,000 mg/kg in dietary foods for babies (category 13.1.5.2) and the particular vulnerability of that population.
2017Regulatory reviewEFSA Journal, re-evaluation of modified starches (E 1451 and related)