Bromine builds up in body tissues
Unlike most food additives that are rapidly metabolised and excreted, bromine from BVO accumulates in fatty tissue throughout the body, including fat deposits around organs, the liver, heart and brain. This bioaccumulation means exposure is not dose-limited to what is consumed on any single occasion. The higher and more prolonged the intake, the greater the tissue burden.
BVO leaves residues of brominated triglycerides in body fat and fatty tissue in the liver, heart and brain after repeated consumption.
2024Regulatory reviewUS FDA, review of BVO safety evidence, cited in Federal Register revocation 2024
Case reports from the 1970s documented clinical bromine toxicity (bromism) in heavy consumers of BVO-containing drinks, with symptoms including headaches, nausea, memory loss and impaired coordination.
ObservationalHorowitz et al., JAMA (multiple case reports); cited in CSPI BVO summary
Thyroid hormone disruption in animal studies
Animal studies conducted in collaboration with the US National Institutes of Health found that BVO exposure produced elevated bromide levels in blood, raised concentrations of brominated triglycerides in heart and lung tissue, and measurable changes to thyroid hormone levels and thyroid gland structure. Thyroid hormones regulate metabolism and are critical to brain development, particularly in early life.
Rat studies showed increased blood bromide, elevated brominated triglycerides in tissues, and thyroid hormone level changes alongside structural changes to the thyroid gland.
2024AnimalNational Institutes of Health animal study, cited as primary evidence in FDA 2024 revocation
The FDA cited thyroid effects as the key toxicological basis for revoking BVO's authorisation in July 2024, concluding the existing evidence no longer supported a finding of safety.
2024RegulatoryFDA, Federal Register: Revocation of Authorization for Use of Brominated Vegetable Oil in Food (2024-14300)
UK and EU banned it decades before the US
BVO was removed from permitted use in the UK in the 1970s and was not included in the EU's harmonised list of approved food additives when Regulation 1333/2008 was finalised. The US was an outlier in retaining authorisation until 2024. The eventual FDA ban brought US rules into alignment with the position the UK and EU had already held for decades.
Brominated vegetable oil is not included on the UK FSA list of approved food additives and E numbers, and has not been a permitted food additive in the UK since the 1970s.
RegulatoryUK Food Standards Agency, Approved additives and E numbers
BVO is not an authorised food additive under EU Regulation 1333/2008 (Annex II) and therefore is not permitted in food products placed on the EU market.
2008RegulatoryEuropean Commission, EU Regulation 1333/2008 Annex II
The FDA finalised the revocation of BVO's food additive authorisation in July 2024, effective August 2024, with a one-year compliance period ending August 2025.
2024RegulatoryFDA, Federal Register 2024-14300